Baked Reuben Sandwich

When ordering from a delicatessen I am always drawn to the Reuben Sandwich. It has everything I love in a sandwich salty, cheesy, pickley, and saucy!  Years ago I remembered eating this version of a Reuben Sandwich with my husbands step-sister.  Recently I’ve gone on a rampage ripping through my recipe box and cookbooks looking for the recipe, because I was sure that I had it somewhere. Couldn’t find it. So I emailed Karen to see if she had it.  She did!  And the funny thing is she said I had made it for her and gave her the recipe….I swear, what is my brain going to be like in another five years?  Gone I tell ya!

Thankfully Karen has her wits about her and keeps good track of her recipes, because this one is a winner, and I’m glad to have it back!

I was thinking of this sandwich in terms of St Patricks Day but really the Reuben Sandwich has nothing to do with St. Patty or Ireland….but let’s just go with it since Ireland is known for it’s Corned Beef and corned beef happens to be a main player in this sandwich.  I think we can sneak this one in as a St. Patricks Day recipe…whaddayasay?!


Unfortunately no one else in my family (with the exception of my Seestor, she doesn’t count because she doesn’t live under my roof) appreciates a good Reuben like myself.  I think that must be why I lost track of this recipe.  It was lost but now it’s found! Can I get an Amen?! a Hallelujah maybe?

This recipe is simple in every way!  Literally,  5 minutes prep, 1 hour to allow to rise, 20 minutes for baking.


Here are the goodies!



It must be the German in me but I love sauerkraut!  I could eat it cold straight from the can with a fork…but I won’t, because I if I did my husband would not sleep in the same bed with me for at least a fortnight!  Unless of course I supplied him with a gas mask!  Ha.   So anyway…..sorry was that TMI?

Drain the sauerkraut well, pressing out any excess liquid with a paper towel.



I start by thawing the bread dough over night in the refrigerator.  Then I roll it out into a 12 x 18″ rectangle.
Then it’s time to layer on the goodies.  Spoon dressing down the middle, layer on Swiss cheese, and corned beef, then pile the sauerkraut.  Cut dough from the filling out to the edge in 2 inch strips.

Fold strips of dough across filling, creating a criss cross pattern.  Pinch the ends together to seal in the goodies.


Transfer to a lightly greased baking sheet, cover, and let rise for 1 1/2 hours.

Preheat oven to 400 degrees.



After Reuben loaves have risen beat one egg, and brush each of the loaves lightly with egg wash.



Spinkle with caraway seeds.  Pop in a preheated 400 degree oven for 20 minutes.





Oh HO HO come to Momma!  In the words of my father “tasty and toolicious for sure”!  I know just go with it…he’s really a sweet man.

Happy St. Patricks Day!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. 1
    Aggie :

    Can I come live under your roof, I swear I appreciate a good Reuben!!! I’ve been waiting for you to share what that glorious cheesy bread since I saw the pic the other day. I am a sucker for Reuben’s, love everything about them. Yours all baked up together like that is just glorious.

  2. 2

    My guys would go crazy for this sandwich!

  3. 3

    Mmmm! If I have leftover corned beef I’ve gotta give this a try! My hubby especially loves Reubens!

    • 3.1
      Sheila :

      I hope you do try! Enjoy! You can easily cut this in half you don’t have to make two loaves….I’m sure you can figure that out ; )

  4. 4
    Cindy :

    Do you know how much I love “tasty and toolicious”??

  5. 5

    You can have a Hallelujah and an Amen. I love a good reuben and LOVE this recipe so, so much. Pinning and making soon!

    • 5.1
      Sheila :

      Thanks friend. Hope you enjoy…wish we could share with a Guinness today ; )

  6. 6
    Heather Nesbit :

    I am totally making this with our left over corn beef…looks AWESOME!!!

  7. 7
    Demetria Friberg :

    This SANDWICH makes me what to cry! (and I think you know why!!) Boo HOoooooo….crying myself all the way to the store to get the ingredients to make this SOON!! Glad recipe was FOUND…here is your AMEN.


  1. […] Baked Reuben Sandwich […]

  2. […] Baked Reuben Sandwich with spicy! Thousand Island for dipping, can you say “dangood!”? […]

  3. […] 7. Baked Reuben Sandwich – this can be made with ham and cheese, or as a pizza sandwich.  This recipe is so flexible!  My favorite flavor of this baked sandwich is still the reuben.  This is also great party food!! Think Michigan State vs Alabama game food!  Go Green! […]

  4. […] favorite version of this sandwich is the Reuben with thousand island dressing for dipping!  Baked sandwiches make great party food.  You can make […]