Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream


First of all I need to thank Dorothy S. for leaving me a comment that led to the making of this ice cream.  Dorothy your comment most definitely has changed the lives of my family as well as many others!  Thank you!   Thank you!

Hug, hug, kiss, kiss, big hug, leetle kiss. (name that movie)

Dorothy left me her 2cents about how quick and easy it is to use Jell-O pudding to make the base for ice cream.  I had a WOW!  Why didn’t I think of that moment.  Genius.  Simply genius!


The number one ice cream and or ice cream topping ordered by my children, when we go out for ice cream,  is Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough.  I decided to give homemade chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream a whirl using the Jell-O pudding method.

The result?

Creamy, rich, smooth, perfectly sweet vanilla ice cream with buttery nibbles of cookie dough tucked in it!

IMG_8459I enlisted these two doofenschmertzes to whip up a batch of edible cookie dough.  They did so with pleasure, eating approximately one-quarter of the dough in the process.  Which was really not a problem there was plenty left over for the ice cream.  I love these doofenschmertzes, just in case you wondered.



IMG_8479Then I had the girls plop bite sized nuggets of the cookie dough on a parchment line cookie sheet and place the sheet in the freezer for at least one hour.  I took this picture so you could get an idea how big my nuggets were.  I’d equal them to a half a bite….or a nibble.



IMG_8463Heavy whipping cream, whole milk, one small package Jell-O instant vanilla pudding, and vanilla extract is all you will need to make the base for this ice cream flavor.  Do you spy a photo bomber?  Let me know if you see doofenschmertze number three.


Ribbet collageWhisk together heavy cream, whole milk, instant pudding and vanilla until it starts to become thick and coats the back of a wooden spoon, or your finger…..which ever you prefer.  Pour ice cream base in to your freezing cold ice cream maker bowl, and churn until the consistency of soft serve ice cream.  In this case it took about 20 minutes.  The colder your ice cream makers bowl is the faster your ice cream will freeze for you.


IMG_8477When the ice cream is the right consistency (soft serve) take chocolate chip cookie dough nuggets from freezer and get a freezer safe container ready.


IMG_8484Spread half of the vanilla ice cream in to your container, sprinkle with one cup of cookie dough, layer the other half of the ice cream on top and repeat with cookie dough.  Pressing the cookie dough nuggets down in to the mixture as you layer.  Cover ice cream and freeze for at least 2 hours before serving….or honestly dig right in if you must.  I will never ever hold digging right in to homemade ice cream against you!





IMG_8485There you have it the easiest darn ice cream you will ever make and it is seriously sinful!  Thanks again Dorothy S. for sharing your super time-saving rich and creamy ice cream secret with us!

There are so many flavor options you could make with Jell-O pudding which one would you try?





Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. 1

    What a fun (and delicious!) activity to do with the kids. Love it!

  2. 2
    cassie :

    This looks so loaded with cookie dough! That is my one beef with store-bought cookie dough ice cream – there is NEVER enough! love this!
    cassie recently posted..Roasted Garlic Brown Butter HummusMy Profile

  3. 3

    This chocolate chip cookie dough definitely gives Dairy Queen a run for her money! The more chunks the better!

  4. 4

    We add pudding mix to just about everything! And cookie dough is our favorite 🙂
    Kristen recently posted..So Easy, So Good {Recipe: Black Bean Corn Cheese Quesadillas}My Profile

    • 4.1
      Sheila :

      It seriously is THE secret ingredient! My mom has been adding it to cake mixes for years, and now I put it in my chocolate chip cookie dough recipe too! I need to try your smoothie/shakes with it in there ; )

  5. 5

    Yum! Looks so amazingly tasty. We don’t have an ice cream maker, but we can definitely still do the edible cookie dough. 🙂

    Is the movie reference “Despicable Me”? LOVE that movie!
    Jennifer V. Miller recently posted..An Honor-Based Approach to Career DevelopmentMy Profile

  6. 6

    Very clever idea. We don’t get American style pudding mixes in the grocery stores but I can order it. I’m going to give it a try. There are times that quickies are fun.
    Maureen | Orgasmic Chef recently posted..Simple Chicken Salad Sandwich RollMy Profile

  7. 7
    Des :

    Hold me.
    Des recently posted..Pico de Gallo Quinoa BurgersMy Profile

  8. 8
    Sylvia :

    I never thought of using pudding mix in ice cream-what a great idea! Time to pull out the ice cream maker! Movie reference was to “Nacho Libre”! ooXXOx Love that movie!

    • 8.1
      Sheila :

      Yes!! Nachooo Libreee! Love that movie ; D Thanks for stopping by. Hope you enjoy yourself some homemade icecream soon!


  1. […] Cookie Dough. Your kids are bound to love this recipe from Eat 2gather. It’s loaded with chocolate chip cookie dough just like you’re sneaking it before you bake it! […]

  2. […] Cookie Dough. Your kids are bound to love this recipe from Eat 2gather. It’s loaded with chocolate chip cookie dough just like you’re sneaking it before you bake it! […]