Molasses Cookies

For the most part I bake cookies that my kids request.  Chocolate Chip primarily. Or maybe sometimes Monster Cookies.  Growing up we rarely had Chocolate Chip Cookies, if we did it was a huge treat.  Might have had something to do with the cost of chocolate chips.  My Mom often made Molasses Cookies, peanut butter, oatmeal, and sometimes potato chip cookies.  Yes I said potato chip cookies!  I promise I’ll share my version of these cookies soon.   Do you see a pattern?  All of these cookies have ingredients that are easily found in most pantries.

I decided it was high time I revisited some of the cookies of my youth!  My kiddos need to expand their cookie palate for heavens sake!

The only difference in these cookies from the recipe that my mom makes is that I use half butter half shortening.  I love what butter does to cookies.  In my opinion it makes them crisper and chewier, and lovelier!  But on the other hand shortening helps a cookie hold it’s shape.  This is all just my own opinion, no baking school, or science to back it up. What are you thoughts on Butter vs. Shortening in cookies?  Which to do you prefer?

These cookies come together quickly.  You will need to pop them in the refrigerator for about 30 minutes before rolling into balls.


And plunging them into course sugar .  I don’t roll the whole ball around I just plop it in and place it on the baking sheet sugar side up.


Take a glass of some sort and give the cookies a gentle squishing.


Hell-ooooo purdy cookie I can’t wait to sink my teeth into you!





Before you go I just want to give you a few Molasses Cookie baking tips…..

If at all possible keep the dough cold while you are baking these cookies.  Between baking pop the bowl back in the refirgerator.  It is a subtle but can you see the cookie on the left was from cold dough, and the cookie on the right was from dough that had become warm.  The cold dough cookie holds its shape better, and is chewy but not as flat…does that make sense.  It is not a big deal, but something worth noting.


You want to take the cookies out of the oven after 10 minutes even if they don’t quite look done, and let them cool completely on cookie sheet.  They will continue to bake on the hot baking sheet and become perfectly chewy this way.  When I made these cookies for Kens co-workers I used the large Pampered Chef cookie scooper it makes quite a large cookie, but perfect sized so the Docs can grab just one instead of feeling the need to grab two, because really it’s hard to eat just one of these Molasses Cookies.  OH! and we didn’t even touch on the topic of dunking!

Are you a dunker?

So this is how you do it baby…..

Do I see an alien reflection in my cup-a-Jo?  Omagerd call in the National Guard!!! Tharz been an alien invasion in my kitchen.  If you don’t hear from me by Wednesday call in the troops!

Molasses Cookies…in my mind, what’s left of it (since the aliens invaded it), are the best dunking cookies….well next to Windmill Cookies.  What are Windmill Cookies you ask?  A delicious W.Mi treat that’s what they are!  I may have to share that cookie recipe too!

Ok well, enjoy these tasty morsels.

Much luv, Mrs MC Dunker


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. 1

    This looks like it would be a good cookie to have with my coffee. If you get a chance stop by my blog Recipe for Life and check out some of my family favorite recipes at:
    Deborah H. Bateman-Author

  2. 2
    Kirstin :

    My favorite molasses cookie recipe is Paula Deen’s recipe for ginger cookies, using butter-flavor Crisco. I generally prefer to use butter in cookies, but sometimes vegetable shortening works better.

  3. 3

    Love molasses cookies so much! These look incredible. And big cookies are always better in my book 🙂

    • 3.1
      Sheila :

      I’m with you bigger is better! Bigger muffins, scones, slices of pie! Thanks for stopping by, Sheila

  4. 4

    These are one of Rich’s favorites!!

  5. 5

    Oh I’ve never had molassess cookies. They look so good!

    • 5.1
      Sheila :

      GASP! Well when you come to visit this Summer I will have a platter of them waiting for you ; ) with coffee lotsa coffee! xoxo

  6. 6

    I love these. They sound so good. I’ll have to try these. We’re having a party at Tumbleweed Contessa – What’d You Do ThisWeekend? These would be a great hit. Hope you can bring them over.
    Have a great day!
    Linda (The Contessa)

  7. 7
    Karen :

    Yum – those look delish! This weekend I’m going to expand my families cookie palate with these too! I

  8. 8

    I love to bake cookies. These sound great. Love your pictures. Thank you for sharing these.

    Linda (The Contessa)

  9. 9
    Jennie :

    This is the recipe I’ve been looking for! Absolutely melts in your mouth!

    • 9.1
      Sheila :

      I’m so happy that you enjoyed them as much as my family has! Thanks for stopping by, come back soon ; ) xoxox Sheila

  10. 10
    cj :

    Would love to invite you to share your food photos with us over at Food Foto Gallery . com – There’s no complicated approval process like the big sites. Any photos related to food (that are not watermarked) are accepted & get posted automatically. We also share our daily faves on social media, giving exposure to food bloggers when we can. Let me know if you have any questions and hope to see you at the site 🙂